Showing posts with label Benjamin Graham. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Benjamin Graham. Show all posts

Wednesday, February 11, 2015

Active v. Passive - The Secret to Winning the Loser's Game



This is the final post on active v. passive investing but before moving on let me briefly summarize.

  • Academic evidence points overwhelmingly to indexing being the best way for the vast majority of people to invest. Index funds should form the biggest part of every portfolio.
  • Mathematically, after costs, the average returns of a passive investor have to exceed the average returns of an active investor.
  • The market cap-weighted index reflects the consensus view of the market and therefore is the ideal starting point for a passive investor.

But the cap-weighted index isn’t perfect and, depending on how much risk you’re prepared to take, you may want to tilt the portfolio towards other types of risk, or beta, such as small company or value stocks.

Again beta is a measure of overall market risk. But what about alpha? That’s the name given to any return provided by an investment over and above the benchmark index.
First and foremost you should be indexing. Alternatively you could tilt your portfolio towards different types of risk.

But is there ever a case for chasing alpha - either by choosing stocks yourself or by employing an active fund manager?

Professor Ken French from Tuck School of Business says: “That’s a great question. Does it make sense for the average investor to invest in an active fund? What I know is that the active investor who does invest in an active fund has to expect to lose relative to a passive strategy.”

Professor John Cochrane from the University of Chicago says: “I take a dim view of active management. For any investor to invest, you have to understand why the person you’re giving your money to is in the half that’s going to make money, and not the half that’s going to lose money. What’s special about him? What’s special about you that you know how to evaluate him?”

Much evidence is stacked against active fund management. But, say for example, in spite of everything academia has said, you still want to take a gamble with part of your portfolio, how do you choose an active fund from the thousands of funds available?

Daniel Godfrey from the Investment Management Association says: “Well certainly not just by looking at past performance. A consumer would need to do a number of things. Firstly they can just offset the decision-making altogether and go to an independent financial adviser, and many do. And they will select funds for them, and that may be a mix of active and passive funds, and that’s a perfectly sensible thing to do.”

Value investing is particularly worth investigating - as are the writings of the man usually credited with founding it - the British-born American academic and professional investor Benjamin Graham.

Like Sharpe and Fama, Graham’s aim was to take the guesswork out of picking stocks. He famously inspired one of his pupils, Warren Buffett. And Buffett’s subsequent success is testimony to the validity of Graham’s approach.

Buffett has described Graham’s book The Intelligent Investor as by far the best book about investing ever written. In it Graham wrote that investment is most intelligent when it is most businesslike.

In his preface to the fourth edition of the book, Buffett said: The sillier the market’s behavior, the greater the opportunity for the business-like investor. Follow Graham and you will profit from folly rather than participate in it.

Whichever route you go down - passive, active or somewhere in between - your behavior is absolutely critical - particularly at times when emotions are running high. Everyone knows the idea is to buy low and sell high, but time and again we do the precise opposite.

Many investors pile in just as the market reaches a top. Then, even worse, they bail out just as prices reach the bottom and are bound to rise again. That kind of behavior is sadly all too typical, and even the professionals are prone to it. The effect on the long-term value of our investments can be catastrophic.

So, how do we as investors curb that sort of self-destructive behavior? Well, one way is to have an automated approach to investing. So, once you’ve chosen a strategy and the level of risk you’re prepared to take, you leave your investments exactly as they are. Either once or no more than twice a year you should rebalance your portfolio to realign it with your risk tolerance. But again, this can be done automatically.

Merryn Somerset Webb from MoneyWeek says, “There are lots of styles that work over the long term. Value works, dividend investing works, momentum investing works if you get it right. All sorts of things work. But they only work if you stick with them."

It also helps to have a financial adviser to keep you on track. Charles Ellis says: “There are two main roles for an adviser. One is to help individuals understand themselves and what their real financial purposes are, and what their anxieties would be. And the second is to hold the client’s hand and encourage them to stay in it for the long term.”

Vanguard founder Jack Bogle says: “Why in the name of peace do we pay any attention to the stock market? It's a giant distraction to the business of investing.”

Of course it doesn’t help that we’re constantly hearing about the markets. There are specialist magazines. Almost every major newspaper has a money section. There are radio shows and, of course, entire television channels devoted to the latest on the markets and where the so-called experts think they’re heading.

And that, in a nutshell, is the secret to winning the loser’s game. First, choose a strategy that’s based on evidence - ideally one designed to capture the returns of the whole market - and then tailor it to your attitude to risk. Secondly, stick to your strategy through thick and thin. Rebalance your portfolio, yes, but most important of all, stay the course.

CBlakely CFP®, CTFA        02/2015

Sources: Winning the Loser’s Game – Charles D. Ellis;  Robin Powell: How to Win the Losers Game – SensibleInvesting.tv Link to the video

Thursday, June 30, 2011

Why You Should Invest for Dividends

As a bond maven I get that coupon income dominates total return. The same is true with equities, even more so, dividends have dominated stock market returns historically and are likely to continue dominating future returns.

We buy stocks because we think they will "go up" and we can sell them for a gain. But think about it. Stocks go up presumably because the business is worth more. A business is necessarily worth more if it has large and rising distributions of cash (dividends) to company owners (stockholders). Unless you subscribe to a vast greater-fool theory - wherein someone is always willing to pay you more than you paid for a stock regardless of its "worth" - the final buyer has to be buying with the expectation of holding it in perpetuity based on its intrinsic value. If you are holding a stock with little expectation of selling it , the biggest value it generates is the cash dividend you receive from it. In the daisy chain of buyers and sellers, it mostly comes down to cash!

The point of investing in stocks may be access to cash streams in the form of a dividend, but the reality is that throughout the history of the modern markets speculation in stocks has made up a significant portion and at times the majority of market activity - this is true currently. Viewing the stock market as a casino where you can come away a winner overnight has been an all to common fallacy to many investors. Its the same logic that leads people, otherwise rational, to habitually buy lottery tickets.

The mack daddy of value investing, Benjamin Graham, devotes the entire first chapter of "The Intelligent Investor" to differentiating between investing and speculating. For him, "an investment operation is one which, upon thorough analysis promises safety of principal and an adequate return. Operations not meeting these requirements are speculative." Graham necessarily set the bar high,:" investment is serious business - everything else is speculation."

Dividends dominate the components of total return. Total return, in any given measurement period, is the combination of the income received in the form of a dividend plus the change in the asset value - the stock price movement - both divided by the starting asset value. Whether looking a data going back over the last 80 years or longer, about half the average annual return from from stocks (about 4.5 percent) comes directly from the dividend. The other half come from capital appreciation, a rise in the price of the stock. And what is the reason for the capital appreciation, or at least the lion's share of it? Increased dividend distributions! The market's aggregate dividend distribution has grown at a compound rate of 4.4 percent since 1926. That is, of the markets' total return of 9.7 percent since 1926, about 80 percent of it came from dividends. Basically stocks go up because dividends go up!

How do you invest for dividends? First, determine whether to do it yourself or pay a professional. A lot of basic research is available on the Internet and discount brokers provide decent research and the ability to buy and safekeep your securities at a modest cost. There are several good books you can use to educate yourself and help build a proper portfolio. With that said and only partly out of self-interest, do I earnestly recommend the latter course of action. As full-time managers of dividend focused products we have substantial human resources and technology at our disposal. This is no guaranty of making a lot of money but due to risk controls and systems put in place over the last several years the chances of losing money are low.

CBlakely  CFP, CTFA  06/2011

Sources: Manias, Panics and Crashes: A History of Financial Crises, The Intelligent Investor, Shiller database, Yale Univ. http://www.econ.yale.edu/shiller/data.htm